banner4copy

Energy industry column

Dutch IGCC pioneers chalk up pain and gain
Site manager talks of 5000 plant modifcations [June 07]

Emergency response is behind schedule in the European public sector
Commission threatens legal action against lax COMAH planning [May 07]

A new refining industry in Europe's Asian Corridor
South East Privatisations full steam ahead [Apr 07]

Commission proposes milestone energy proposal
A sea change in climate policy [Mar 07]

Replace fuel oil with distillate?
But how, ask refiners [Feb 07]

Cancelled projects will sustain margins
66 new refineries. 180 upgrading projects and another 180 for clean fuels [Jan 07]

“Marine distillate not fuel oil from 2010”
Tanker association shocks bunker fuels world [Dec 06]

Branson's biofuels megastore
Virgin Fuels has already invested heavily in new fuels [Nov 06]

You heard it here first: refinery CO2 storage a reality in Norway
Mongstad told to sequestrate [Oct 06]

Buncefield 2: Investigation critical
A breathtaking overfilling equivalent to 50 open firehoses of gasoline – for hours! [Sep 06]

Where now for Swedish Class 1 diesel
Oil companies at each other's throats over the need for Europe's cleanest diesel [Aug 06]

My slow awakening to climate change
This is the article that marked my epiphone and outraged climate sceptics [Jul 06]

The luckiest motorist alive
The Buncefield investigation tells of the driver who stalled – and then restarted – his car inside the gas plume [Jun 06]

Safety row goes on over Europe's largest LNG terminal
liquid gas safety caused a firey debate here at the magazine too [May 06]

New WHO guidelines on city air quality put focus on diesel
particulates are still a major killer in failing European cities [Apr 06]

Would LNG really 'evaporate harmlessly' in an accident?
Some experts think maybe not [Mar 06]

Another lesson in the thermobaric bomb
But the physics of Buncefield comes as a surprise [Feb 06]

Fat margins, large pay rises, small clichés
Last new year I asked if the good times would continue. They did [Jan 06]

Spare a thought for the oil-rich
Join me at this festive time in sparing a thought for the fantastically wealthy [Dec 06]

But will the good times keep on rolling?
- some rellish the highs of a hot fuels and process technology market, others are bracing themselves for the decent[Nov 05]

Carbon storage and the zero emissions refinery
- the arguments are stacking up for fundamental changes in refi nery design [Oct 05]

Everything just changed
-Bush at G8 statement has massive implications [Sept 05]

E85 and high octane gasolines
- some are whacky some profitable [August 05]

The problem of small-minded young engineers
- at Europe's largest chem eng meeting [July 05]

New Permit Regulations
- a trickle of small cap projects became a flood [June 05]

Biodiesel newbuilds and a new green superfuel
- The new Neste Oil looks to clean up [May 05]

Spilled wine and our split industry
- Exxon Mobil CEO targeted on Kyoto entry-into-force day [April 05]

Drilling down into the prospects for IGCC
- Refinery power a nuclear alternative? [March 05]

The beginning of the start of the end of oil
- A painful 100-year adjustment [Feb 05]

Biodiesel newbuilds and a new green superfuel

Greenergy will go ahead and build its first biodiesel plant in the Humber Estuary in the UK, near to the ConocoPhillips refinery. Greenergy may be a seasoned ‘early bird’ in new fuels, but it certainly won’t have the biofuels market to itself by the time its plant is up and running.

I mentioned the UK independent’s plans in my January ‘look-ahead’ column. Well, now they’ve got the finance lined up and, assuming they get don’t get snared by red tape, then they’re on course to start producing 100,000tpy of fatty acid methyl ester by Spring next year. Others are moving in too, including an oil company promising a next generation process and a diesel superfuel.

Although fuels from vegetables and animals aren’t new in Europe, the UK is expected by the end of the year to see six-fold growth in biofuels, a heading which can encompass biodiesel, bio-gaseous fuel and bioethanol and bio etbe/mtbe.

Biofuels directive

The UK is not alone in that kind of growth. The Biofuels Directive (2003/30/EC) has European member states generally on a timetable to ensure that 5.75% of road fuels market share is biofuel by 2010. According to the directive, they should have hit 2% share by now. But European directives aren’t laws. They’re an agreement to make laws. It’s generally necessary to get your own sense of how far the member states are on track with their legislative work, and how effective their laws, tax changes, and other sticks and carrots are being in creating change.

The capital projects are lining up now, that’s clear. Near to where Greenergy intends to build its biodiesel plant (a little further north), Biofuels Corporation – a publicly listed start-up put together by two Australians – is building the world’s largest biofuels manufacturing plant. It expects to start its 250,000tpy biodiesel plant this year and possibly to build a second stage to double that capacity. While Greenergy has a memo of understanding to supply ConocoPhillips, Biofuels Corporation has a deal with Dutch independent refining and logistics operator, Petroplus.

Petroplus has good track record on the forecourt and an excellent asset for ULSD production at the former ICI/Phillips refinery nearby on Teesside. Petroplus has had a rough experience on the Dutch stock exchange and is going private again, but claims to be leaner and stronger as a result. Against Greenergy’s already somewhat established GlobalDiesel brand, Petroplus is fielding Bio-Plus.

Neste invests €100m

Oil companies are not taking a lead in biodiesel technology, with the exception of Neste Oil – formerly part of Fortum– which has gone public on plans to build a 170,000tpy plant of its own, located beside the vast and growing 4mtpy diesel plant at Porvoo refinery. Neste will use its own “next generation” technology and says it will invest Euros 100m, a figure larger than the announced capitalisation of the two UK projects put together.

So why spend so much more money? Kimmo Rahkamo, Executive Vice President, Components, Neste Oil, told me there’s a lot of excitement at Neste about their plans. He says they’re going to spend more money to get a process with much more feedstock flexibility and produce a product like no other on the market today – including GTL diesels.

“Others are using a esterification process; we’re isomerising and hydrogenating the molecules to get a cetane number of up to 99 and a very good cloud point [important for their Finnish and Baltic States retailing operation],” he says.

He says Neste is the first oil company in the market with its own process and manufacturing project.

But how, I asked, does he justify the very large investment? “Well, apart from the improved feedstock economics compared to our rather constrained competitors, we’ll have an amazing quality. We’re starting to see a premium diesel market, for example in Germany you can buy a diesel blended with 5-10% GTL diesel and it’s getting a 5 eurocent premium.”

Rahkamo explains that their plans rely in part on hydrogen capacity from a residue hydrocracker at the Porvoo refinery.

Aside from producers, testing organisations typically have a good finger on the pulse of emerging trends in fuels. Intertek Group confirms that there are a lot of players taking an interest in product quality for the emerging biofuels market.

“We're seeing a great deal of activity in bio-fuels testing – in everything from animal to agricultural feedstocks” says Dr Andrew Swift, Vice President of Caleb Brett’s global Outsourcing Division. Swift says there has been a big pick-up in Europe, Australia and the US for bio-fuel analysis and testin: “I can see this globally across our organisation, where meeting the increasing demand for bio-fuels testing and quality certification is part of our core competence. Testing volumes are up, apparently as projects move from the pilot plant phase – initiatives backed by governments or grant assistance in one way or another – to commercial-scale projects backed by venture capital and other investment. Reliable testing accelerates both the route to market for these new producers and the return on their capital”.

There’s rather a lot of biofuels capacity already on the ground in Europe. Germany and Austria have led the way in biodiesel, with industries which have benefited from tax incentives for some years. France has had ETBE in gasoline and was a leader in biodiesel before Germany took its lead. Italy has seen biodiesel used for heating oil. The latter market has been the testing ground for the Novaol/Ballestra technology and engineering partnership that are supplying the Greenergy project.

Biofuels Corporation is using Austrian technology from Energea to build its plant.

Lurgi of Germany is another major technology player and so is Westfalia. Both have played an important part in the 2million tpy German biofuels market.

A good source of competence in biofuels is the Austrian Biofuels Institute (www.biodiesel.at), a largely non-profit organisation run on association lines, whose expert panel has advised on biofuels developments in Europe and Australia.

The organisation has published a CD Rom which tackles standardisation issues, a report on 17 best-case biodiesel plants and other items of interest.

Chairman, Werner Koerbitz, is clearly excited to see projects materialising now, after a lot of hard work advocating the benefits of biofuels.

The pebble in his shoe is the backyard refining industry that has grown up over recent years and ‘reinvents the wheel’ on an almost monthly basis.

Not unlike the early days of mineral oil refining, small open vessel refineries are appearing everywhere: “We see it from Denmark to Paraguay – the local inventor who has created a wonder process and driven his tractor 100km on the resulting liquid,” says Koerbitz. “The internet is full of them, the local paper thinks they’re a genius, they’re proud and the product is awful.”

To contrast that ‘grass roots’ activity, he says there’s a very serious body of technology and expertise ready to undertake the demanding projects that are now appearing.

Download Energy Industry Resumé with work samples
Screen (665k)
Print

Profile: Tim Lloyd Wright MA

Here you'll find a brief profile of my work with international energy, transport and associated environmental issues.

Energy trends articles

You heard it here first: refinery CO2 storage a reality in Norway
Mongstad told to sequestrate [Oct 06]

From the archive...

Over-processed fuel leaves oil tankers adrift
Oil tankers powerless at sea with fuel problems are part of the legacy of Auto Oil II [Nov 03]